‘Just Aren’t Enough Kids’: Choice Schools Feel Effects Of Low Birth Rates, Too

TL;DR

For listenersOffer from Amazon

Turn the school run and nap time into listening time

• Thousands of audiobooks, podcasts and originals
• Listen on your phone, tablet or Echo — also offline
• Cancel anytime

Try Audible free →Free trial for new members

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

Atlanta’s enrollment decline is affecting district schools as well as charter and private schools, according to a report by The 74. The report links the pressure partly to falling birth rates and documents closures, planned consolidations and concerns about reduced services, while noting that the effect varies by school and location.

Falling birth rates and lower enrollment are putting pressure on Atlanta’s district, charter and private schools, according to a report by The 74, challenging the idea that school choice alone explains declining enrollment at neighborhood schools. The report documents two KIPP charter school closures and a private school shutdown, as well as district consolidation plans that have disrupted families and raised concerns about access to support services.

KIPP Soul Primary and Soul Academy, which shared a campus in a predominantly Black neighborhood on Atlanta’s west side, closed in June. The closures followed Atlanta Public Schools’ announcement the previous year that it planned to close or repurpose 16 schools because of declining enrollment. District families affected by the broader plan have until the end of the school year to prepare for fall 2027, while the two charter schools closed sooner.

A small private school for high-achieving students in Atlanta closed abruptly in April. In a letter to families, its board members said applications at private schools across the city were down more than 20%. That figure is the board’s claim as reported by The 74; the article does not provide the underlying application data or specify the comparison period.

Georgia’s fertility rate fell 17% between 2007 and 2023, the report says, citing state figures. It also describes projected declines in incoming kindergarten cohorts in several states, based on an analysis by ExcelinEd. The evidence points to broad demographic pressure, but it does not establish that birth rates alone caused any particular school closure.

Fewer Students, Fewer School Services

Enrollment declines can affect more than whether a building stays open. Schools with fewer students may have difficulty supporting the same staffing and services, while closure or relocation can change how far children travel and whether families can rely on familiar staff. For some students, that disruption is especially concerning to caregivers.

At Atlanta’s Finch Elementary, which is set to consolidate with another school and move, parent Hazel Smith said she values the familiar teachers and principal her five-year-old son knows. She said he has developmental delays and expressed uncertainty about what support and familiarity will be available at the new location. The report does not say that his services will be reduced, but his family’s concerns illustrate the practical stakes of a school move.

The pressure also complicates debates over charter and private schools. District enrollment can be affected by families choosing other options, but the report finds that choice schools are also facing fewer potential students. That does not rule out competition between schools; it means demographic decline is part of the picture and should not be treated as a complete explanation for every local change.

Atlanta’s Wider Enrollment Decline

The report places Atlanta within a national demographic shift. Georgia’s fertility rate declined 17% from 2007 to 2023, similar to the national average, while the article says declines are steeper in some states. An ExcelinEd analysis cited in the report projects nearly 32% fewer children entering kindergarten in New Mexico in 2028; Illinois is close behind, and California recorded 29% fewer births over the period discussed, or 166,306 fewer births. These figures describe different measures and time frames, so they are not direct comparisons of current school enrollment.

District schools continue to face substantial pressure. Federal data cited by The 74 shows school closures rising from 755 in the 2021–22 school year to more than 1,000 last year. The report also cites an August Bureau of Labor Statistics jobs report showing public-school staffing nationally down by about 29,000 employees over the prior year. Enrollment, staffing and closure figures describe related pressures, but do not by themselves establish the cause of any one district’s decision.

Atlanta is among 14 urban districts planning a combined total of nearly 150 school closures in the year covered by a K-12 Dive tracker. Elsewhere, 60 Oakland Unified principals urged their school board to close schools, saying the district could not maintain its existing structure while operating 81 schools with “skeleton services.” Los Angeles Unified, whose enrollment the report says is roughly half its level two decades ago, has begun discussing closures.

““Choice cannot be the scapegoat. There just aren’t enough kids.””

— Cara Candal, ExcelinEd vice president of policy

Causes and Local Effects Vary

The report links falling birth rates to lower enrollment, but it does not quantify how much of each school’s decline is due to demographics rather than family moves, school choice, housing patterns or other factors. The private-school application decline of more than 20% comes from the closed school’s board letter; its dates, method and coverage are not detailed.

It is also unclear how the planned district closures and consolidations will affect staffing, student services and travel arrangements at each site. Smith’s concerns about Finch describe a family’s uncertainty, not a confirmed finding that her son will lose particular support. The cited national staffing and closure totals likewise do not identify the cause of each change.

Closures and Consolidations Ahead

Atlanta families affected by the district’s broader closure plans are expected to make plans for fall 2027, while Finch’s consolidation and move are set to affect students in the next school year. The KIPP Soul schools have already closed. The report does not give a further timeline for the private school that shut down in April.

District decisions and the support available at receiving schools will determine how the changes affect students and families. The article does not provide final enrollment projections or detailed plans for services at every affected site, so the scale of future staffing and access changes remains to be seen.

Key Questions

Why are Atlanta schools facing enrollment pressure?

The 74 report points to declining enrollment and Georgia’s 17% fertility-rate decline from 2007 to 2023. It does not establish that birth rates are the only cause of enrollment losses at any specific school.

Are charter and private schools affected as well as district schools?

Yes. The report describes the closure of two KIPP charter schools and an Atlanta private school, whose board said citywide private-school applications had fallen more than 20%. The report does not provide the application data behind that figure.

Which Atlanta schools are closing or consolidating?

KIPP Soul Primary and Soul Academy closed in June. Finch Elementary is set to consolidate with another school and move. Atlanta Public Schools also announced plans to close or repurpose 16 schools, with district families affected by the broader plan preparing for fall 2027.

What could school closures mean for students?

Closures and moves can change a student’s school location, travel and access to familiar staff. Families and school leaders have also raised concerns about staffing and services, but the report does not confirm specific service reductions at every affected school.

Source: rss